Address the originality of student work and emerging trends in misconduct with this comprehensive solution.
Deliver and grade all types of assessments from anywhere using this modern assessment platform.
This high-stakes plagiarism checking tool is the gold standard for academic researchers and publishers.
This robust, comprehensive plagiarism checker fits seamlessly into existing workflows.
Give feedback and grade assignments with this tool that fosters writing excellence and academic integrity.
Uphold academic integrity, streamline grading and feedback, and protect your reputation with these tools.
Improve student writing, check for text similarity, and help develop original thinking skills with these tools for teachers.
Earlier this week, we shared a list of tactics crowdsourced from our teacher network, aimed at fighting back against contract cheating. We discovered that in-class writing assignments, and only in-class writing assignments, are a popular method for combatting contract cheating.
Not surprising, since plagiarism would be nearly impossible under observation. And yet--let’s put it under a microscope.
What are we getting with in-class assignments?
Many teachers, facing the prevalence of cheating, only assign in-class writing. A higher ed instructor who teaches composition, says, “It’s so common that I stopped assigning take-home papers for undergrads; I assign in-class essays only.” Another, a high school teacher based in the Bay Area states, “I don’t do formal lit crit essays anymore, because of the cheating. Only in-class [writing].”
Educators still assign research-based essays, but the fear of contract cheating is such that in-class writing has taken a permanent seat in the pedagogy of writing instruction. Should in-class writing be a substitute for research essays?
Herein lies a potential problem:
But in-class writing doesn’t have to sacrifice or replace long form research papers. In fact, they can be used as a window into the writing process, through which teachers and students communicate and share feedback. In-class writing opens up possibilities for teachable moments.
One professor of writing at a second tier research institution in the U.S. says she incorporates in-class writing into her process:
“I have students do in-class writing related to the assignment. I also require students to submit (and I offer brief feedback on) process steps. It becomes harder for students to simply purchase and submit an essay this way.”
It’s beautiful to see in-class writing as part of the initial, brainstorming step of the process, that educators are encouraging original thought from the essay’s inception.
Many teachers also have students revise essays in-class, and use multiple drafts as opportunities for peer review as well as teacher feedback, thereby providing scaffolding for the student as they move through essay-writing.
In doing so, students develop the skills to write research papers and fine-tune critical thinking skills crucial to post-academic life. And it makes contract cheating all the more difficult, as multiple drafts would be more challenging to procure from essay mills or individual ghostwriters.
Instead, what we have is teachers supporting students.
In-class writing assignments don’t have to exist at the sacrifice of research-based, long form papers. Using in-class writing is critical not only as a diagnostic baseline for writing--but also a supplement for the writing process, which is best made transparent. In conjunction with a transparent writing process, complete with feedback, in-class writing is an effective deterrent.
But deterrence only goes so far.
Cath Ellis, Associate Dean in the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences at the University of New South Wales in Australia, is a notable anti-plagiarism activist and researcher. She confirms, “The longterm solution isn’t excluding types of writing--but supplementing,” as we note in this blog post. There has to be a multi-pronged approach, both from the perspective of pedagogy as well as tools.
Want to address contract cheating at your institution? Learn more about Turnitin Originality.
We asked a number of secondary and higher education teachers for their boots-on-the-ground tactics to fight back...
We reached out to Dave Tomar, a former essay mill writer and author of The Shadow Scholar, an exposé of contract...
Educators are consistently advised to create a “culture of integrity” within our classrooms. So how do we go about...
Turnitin blog posts, delivered straight to your inbox.